Quantitative questions in consulting case interviews aren’t just about getting to the right number — they’re about showing how you think. Firms like McKinsey, BCG, and Bain are looking not only for accuracy but also for clarity, structure, and insights.
Here’s a proven 4-step approach to stand out when facing quantitative problems during your interview:
Step 1: Understand the Question — Really Understand It
Before diving into any calculations, pause and ensure you’re answering the exact question being asked. This may sound basic, but it’s incredibly common to misinterpret the metric or objective — especially when data is presented at the same time the question is asked. If the interviewer is asking for the metric X, your final outcome should deliver the exact metric X, not something similar.
What to do:
- Restate the question clearly
- Clarify any ambiguities about the context, metric, or units
- Confirm your understanding of the data, context, and assumptions
Pro Tip:
As you clarify, start extracting early insights from the charts or numbers. For instance, if you’re given a bar graph, you might say:
“So, if I understand correctly, we’re trying to find the incremental profit from entering Market X. And at first glance, it seems like Market X has lower margins but higher growth potential — I’d like to confirm that.”
This not only shows comprehension, but also engages the interviewer in an analytical conversation from the start showing you are quick on capturing key insights. This puts you in a position to be able to already voice over the key insights of the problem without any math.
Step 2: Lay Out Your Approach — Before Doing the Math
Once you’re clear on the question asked and data presented, take 30–60 seconds to structure your approach. This is where many candidates rush — and lose points. Instead of calculating right away, explain your plan out loud.
What to do:
- Describe the logical steps you’ll follow
- Clearly state any assumptions or missing data you’ll need to ask for
- Choose the most straightforward approach with the fewest calculations possible
Avoid doing any math here. This gives the interviewer a chance to:
- Validate you know how to solve the problem
- Redirect you quickly if you’re going off-track during calculations in step 3
- Follow your logic — which builds trust
Pro Tip:
Be as descriptive as possible stating each step of the calculation on a top-down manner, without necessarily bringing numbers or doing any calculations yet.
Step 3: Execute the Math — Out Loud and Step by Step
Now that your structure is agreed upon, move into the calculations. This is the execution phase, and clarity is key.
What to do:
- Walk the interviewer through your math, step by step
- Speak every number and operation out loud
- Check your math as you go
Why? Because if you make a mistake, the interviewer (or even you) can catch it early and point it out. Talking through your calculations also helps you stay grounded and minimizes mental errors.
Step 4: Get to the “So What”
A case interview isn’t a math test. Numbers are only valuable if you can interpret them. Once you have your result, don’t stop — analyze it.
What to do:
- Ask yourself: What does this mean for the client and problem being discussed?
- Is the result feasible? Are there risks, assumptions, or caveats?
- Could the result change if assumptions shift?
- What’s the next question you’d want to explore?
Even if your number isn’t perfect, showing business judgment in the interpretation can still leave a strong impression.
Bonus Tip: Choose the Simplest Valid Approach
Often, there are multiple ways to calculate a number. During Step 2, choose the approach that:
- Requires the fewest steps or assumptions
- Is easiest to explain
- Avoids complex percentage changes or fractions, if possible
Also, if any data point is missing, ask for it clearly during the structuring phase, not after you’ve already started calculating.
Final Thought
Approaching quantitative questions with this 4-step method ensures that you’re not only solving the math — you’re also demonstrating clear thinking, communication, and business sense. And that’s exactly what McKinsey, BCG, and Bain are looking for.
Get your MBB Pass
Book a session to secure your future at McKinsey, Bain & BCG